Pasadena has the highest concentration of intact Craftsman bungalows and Arts and Crafts architecture in the Los Angeles region — possibly in the country. Neighborhoods like Bungalow Heaven, Madison Heights, and areas near the historic core preserve remarkable examples of this early 20th-century architecture.
Renovating a Craftsman home in Pasadena requires a different mindset than renovating a mid-century ranch or a contemporary infill property. The architectural character of these homes has genuine historic value — and thoughtful renovation honors that value rather than erasing it.
What Defines Craftsman Architecture
Exterior: Low-pitched roofline with wide overhanging eaves; exposed rafter tails and decorative beam ends; front porch with tapered wood columns on stone or brick piers; wood siding (often shiplap or board-and-batten); natural materials throughout.
Interior: Wood trim throughout (typically Douglas fir or red oak stained or painted in natural tones); built-in furniture (bookcases, window seats, buffets); wood-burning fireplace; beamed or coffered ceilings in living areas; wainscoting.
Details: Window divided-light patterns (typically simple 4-over-1 or 6-over-1 double-hung); hardware in oil-rubbed bronze or wrought iron; natural tile (Batchelder-style, Pewabic, or Arts and Crafts reproduction tilework).
What to Preserve vs. Update
Preserve (Non-Negotiably)
Original woodwork. Period fir or oak trim, door and window casing, baseboards, built-in furniture — these are irreplaceable and define the character of the home. Stripping, replacing, or encasing original woodwork destroys Craftsman character permanently.
Original doors and windows. True-divided-light wood windows and solid wood panel doors are period-appropriate. Replacing with modern aluminum or vinyl windows changes the character of the home substantially and typically removes it from historic designation eligibility.
Fireplaces and fireplace surrounds. Original Arts and Crafts tile fireplace surrounds (Batchelder, Malibu, Claycraft) are significant both architecturally and in dollar value. Restoration rather than replacement is almost always the appropriate approach.
Craftsman porch elements. The porch is the face of the home. Original columns, railings, porch decking, and decorative brackets should be restored and maintained.
Update Thoughtfully
Kitchen: Craftsman homes were built with utilitarian kitchens by today's standards. A kitchen renovation that updates function and appliances while using materials consistent with the aesthetic (shaker cabinets, natural stone or butcher block counters, subway tile or Craftsman-era tile backsplash) is appropriate and adds value.
Bathrooms: Original bathrooms can be charming if intact; they can also be genuinely dysfunctional. Renovation that uses period-consistent tile (white subway, hex mosaic, Craftsman-accent tile), pedestal sinks or simple vanities, and appropriate fixtures maintains character while improving function.
Systems: Electrical, plumbing, HVAC — update these entirely. Original electrical (knob-and-tube) and galvanized plumbing should be replaced. A comfortable Craftsman home with updated systems is superior to an authentic Craftsman home with 1910 wiring.
HPOZ Considerations in Pasadena
Pasadena's Historic Preservation Overlay Zone (HPOZ) covers many of the Craftsman neighborhoods. Within an HPOZ:
- Exterior alterations require review and approval by the Pasadena Historic Preservation Commission
- Interior renovations are generally not subject to HPOZ review
- Certain changes (new windows, additions visible from the street, demolition of historic elements) require specific approvals
Work within a Pasadena HPOZ requires understanding which changes are permitted by right and which require commission review. We have experience working in Pasadena's HPOZ zones and can guide clients through the process.
Craftsman Renovation Costs in Pasadena
| Project | Cost Range | |---------|-----------| | Kitchen renovation (Craftsman-appropriate) | $55,000–$120,000 | | Bathroom renovation (period tile, appropriate fixtures) | $22,000–$50,000 | | Woodwork restoration (stripping, refinishing, repair) | $8,000–$30,000 | | Full home renovation | $180,000–$500,000+ |
For Craftsman home renovation consultation in Pasadena, contact us.
Related: Full Home Remodels in Pasadena · Kitchen Cabinet Styles for California Homes